Is it censorship if ISPs voluntarily sign up to it? They aren't mandated by law.
The same way a book shop can voluntarily sell or not sell pornography.
The problem I think is that there does not seem a way to opt-out such a service. IWF covers almost all UK ISPs and there is no way of turning it off AFAIK.
It's a slippery slope and I'd rather not have IWF on my cable connection at all. However it seems I can't do anything about it. There is no other cable supplier except Virgin Media.
It's censorship for most of those ISPs' customers, who were never asked whether they wanted to sign up to IWF's ultra-conservative filtering and - in some instances - not even told abou tit. I know of one person (rar42) who called Virgin Media and was told they weren't filtering. Ironically, VM carry several porno channels on their TV service.
Comments
pabs 10 years, 1 month ago
Govt is doing something similar in .au :(
Link | ReplyKai Hendry 10 years, 1 month ago
Is it censorship if ISPs voluntarily sign up to it? They aren't mandated by law.
Link | ReplyThe same way a book shop can voluntarily sell or not sell pornography.
The problem I think is that there does not seem a way to opt-out such a service. IWF covers almost all UK ISPs and there is no way of turning it off AFAIK.
It's a slippery slope and I'd rather not have IWF on my cable connection at all. However it seems I can't do anything about it. There is no other cable supplier except Virgin Media.
MJ Ray 10 years, 1 month ago
It's censorship for most of those ISPs' customers, who were never asked whether they wanted to sign up to IWF's ultra-conservative filtering and - in some instances - not even told abou tit. I know of one person (rar42) who called Virgin Media and was told they weren't filtering. Ironically, VM carry several porno channels on their TV service.
Link | ReplyNew Comment